Friday, October 31, 2014

Is there a denial of gods movement?

Recently I've noticed, primarily on Twitter but also in other conversations, a discomfort that some atheists have with any mention of an atheist community or an atheist movement. For example, sentiments like "it is extremely important that we never call out irrational beliefs on behalf of a community or collective" and "banding together it makes it easier for theists to win the argument so we should attack from all sides." Sam Harris spoke about this at the 2007 Atheist Alliance International conference. Much of his speech was an argument that atheists shouldn't even use the label 'atheist'. To that point, does anyone call themselves 'non-astrologers'?

I completely agree that the desired end game here - the thing that all atheists want - is not to have to use the word at all. 'Atheism' should be roughly equivalent to 'abigfootism.' At the same time, the very existence of organizations like AAI proves that some atheists have banded together as a community. (Perhaps we should call AAI a sub-community?) Harris himself admits that, despite his discomfort with the term, he still calls himself an atheist because it can be politically useful. I can't get that worked up when I hear individual atheists speaking as if it were a community. Maybe there is a downside but there is also an upside in terms of political expediency. Some atheists are galvanized under a banner.

Here is another example from an exchange I had on Twitter:
Supergirl -- I hate it when I see "us atheists..." or "atheists do... ". Atheism is not a movement, it's just lack of belief in God.
dogsturnleft -- respect for evidence is sort of a movement, no?
Sg -- You don't have to respect evidence to be an atheist. Lack of belief the only prerequisite for atheism.
dtl -- that's one definition. Another is: Denial of the existence of gods. And denial can define a movement.
Sg -- What is the objective of your denial movement? Who defines the objective?
dogsturnleft - the marginalization of bad ideas. People who think beliefs should be based on good evidence.
Sg -- no longer atheism then
dtl -- and you get to decide? Yeah, OK, got it.
Sg -- Crossing the road without looking is a bad idea and has nothing to do with atheism.
dtl -- how about this: The objective is the marginalization of people who argue that gods exist.
Sg -- You'll get passive aggressive again when I counter. So lets move on.

Coming from an atheist, Supergirl's last comment was rather disappointing. It was pulled straight from the believer's playbook. Supergirl ended this exchange by making a claim based on bad evidence. In other words, Supergirl used faith as a conversation stopper. It's the ultimate theist checkmate.

I absolutely hate the notion that the world needs an atheist movement. But I think it does. If we are to move forward, we need to actively marginalize the idea that gods exist, which is one piece in the overall effort to marginalize all beliefs that are based on bad evidence.

No comments:

Post a Comment