If you are ever in an argument and you hear the line "I'm right and you're wrong because I'm an expert", prepare yourself for a flood of childish twaddle. Professor Reza Aslan uses this sophism 6:18 into this YouTube clip: "there's a reason why I don't write books about neuroscience; because I don't have an expertise in neuroscience. I write books about what's going on in the Muslim world because I have an expertise in what's going on in the Muslim world. I actually travel through the Muslim world, I study the Muslim world, I understand the conversations that are taking place. And so I feel like, in a sense, I'm in a better position [than my opponent] to sort of make judgments about what sort of socio- or religious or political developments are taking place within this people of, you know, one and a half billion ... Statements like 'there are millions of Muslims who, you know, have this sort of death cult' are profoundly inaccurate, and are based on nothing except your sort of general impression of a region, and of a religion, that you have a very surface understanding of."
So there you have it. Aslan's uses his credentials as a basis to make judgments about political and religious developments in the Muslim world, and he provides a bit of his CV. Sam Harris, his opponent in this debate, has permission to discuss topics in neuroscience because he has a Ph.D. in neuroscience. Furthermore, according to Aslan, Harris's judgments on political or religious developments in the Muslim world should cede the ground to Aslan because Harris lacks expertise - just as Aslan's opinion on neuroscience would be overruled by Harris. Q.E.D., I guess.
That debate occurred nearly eight years ago but recently Aslan used similar reasoning. At 1:52 he states: "My greatest intellectual heroes are all atheists. Whether I'm talking about Schopenhauer, or Freud, or Marx, or Feuerbach, these were the people who gave birth to the modern world. They were the people who gave birth to the enlightenment. But they were experts in religion. They understood religion, and then criticized it from a place of expertise - and there is lots to criticize about religion ... but what is happening now is that, sort of, a guy sitting in his room watching television, with a blog, has now become a self-described expert on religion, and espouses the most basic, uninformed, and unsophisticated views about religion, from a position of 'intellectualism'. And I think that that's dangerous."
To be clear, what the viewer must understand is that Harris's opinion - one of those guys just sitting in his room, watching television, forming misconceptions - can be dismissed because he isn't an expert. At least not on the topic of religion. Marx understood religion, Harris does not. Aslan yes, Harris no. We also need to understand that Aslan's expertise enables him to magically morph reliable facts into profound inaccuracies. How does that work? Well as it turns out, there actually are millions of Muslims who believe suicide bombing in defense of Islam can be justified. But that doesn't matter because Aslan has expertise.
Harris's statement about death cults isn't inaccurate, and it isn't a judgment based on a general surface impression. It is merely a reiteration of precisely what millions of Muslims said about their faith-based motivations.
What, then, are we to make of this drivel about the supremacy of expertise? Anyone with Aslan's academic credentials - or even, you know, a child - can easily grasp the intellectual bankruptcy of "resumé equals right"-style reasoning. So what is his motivation? Is it mere apologism? Obscurantism? Harris himself wonders: "He cannot possibly believe what he says, because nearly everything he says is a lie or a half-truth calibrated to mislead a liberal audience ... I don’t know what his agenda is, beyond riding a jet stream of white guilt from interview to interview, but he is manipulating liberal biases for the purpose of shutting down conversation on important topics. Given what he surely knows about the contents of the Koran and the hadith, the state of public opinion in the Muslim world, the suffering of women and other disempowered groups, and the real-world effects of deeply held religious beliefs, I find his deception on these issues unconscionable."
I don't know what Aslan's agenda is either. He and Harris accuse each other of the same transgression, that is, trying to shut down conversation on important topics like religious extremism. I've come to the unfortunate conclusion that Aslan has a Straussian M.O. because the only alternative conclusion is outrageous: A respected university professor thinks his credentials provide a knock-out argument against the clear evidence of widespread Muslim support for suicide bombers. When Cenk Uygur asked Aslan to comment on Harris's charge of a hidden agenda, Aslan's response was: "That's called fundamentalism, and it doesn't matter if it's religious fundamentalism or atheist fundamentalism, and it needs to be rejected by all people."
So Sam Harris has a hard time believing that someone as smart as Reza Aslan would abandon empiricism, and that somehow makes Harris an atheist fundamentalist? OK, right...
In 2004, Luke Mitchell wrote about motivations for the war in Iraq: "It is not giving Bush the benefit of the doubt, then, to assume his war is not about oil. It is giving him the benefit of the doubt to assume it is." Whether or not that is true, I see a similar situation here. If you believe that Reza Aslan believes that there is no widespread Mulsim embrace of martyrdom in defense of Islam, you are not giving him the benefit of the doubt. It is giving him the benefit of the doubt to accept that he knows it does exist, and that he is merely lying about it.
No comments:
Post a Comment